top of page
uintent company logo

UX INSIGHTS, EXPERT INTERVIEWS, GAMING UX

Inside the Game: Exploring the State of Gaming UX - Where Fun Meets Function!

UX Insights: Interviews with Industry Experts Part 2

Ever wondered what goes on behind the scenes of game development? Join Laura Donohue and Mark Brady from our UX Alliance partner Sutherland labs as they unveil the fascinating world of UX testing for games. 🚀

5

MIN

Apr 9, 2024

With this series of interviews, we want to show how diverse the field of UX is and what interesting stories our partner companies from the UX Alliance can tell. The UX Alliance is a network of leading UX research and design companies around the globe.

Today, we're speaking with Mark Brady and Laura Donohue, two seasoned professionals from Sutherland Labs, a member of the UX Alliance. Mark, Senior Research Director at Sutherland Labs' Covent Garden office, brings a rich background in design and technology. He specializes in empathetic design, ensuring products and services are user-friendly and enjoyable. His experience spans from app development to comprehensive services, with a focus on continuous iteration and adaptation to change.

Laura Donohue is a skilled professional in playtesting and user research, especially in the gaming sector. At Sutherland Labs, she broadens her expertise in UX testing, delving deep into player interactions with game mechanics, storylines, and environments. Her insights contribute significantly to understanding user experiences in gaming.



Interviewer: Welcome, Laura and Mark. Laura, could you share how you got into testing for games?

Laura: I started in user research for software, then joined Sutherland Labs to diversify my experience. Initially, I did playtesting for indie (=independent) developers before moving to official playtesting at Sutherland.

 

Interviewer: How do you differentiate game testing from traditional QA testing?

Laura: QA testing involves repeatedly playing to identify bugs. Playtesting is more surgical, focusing on player experiences with game mechanics, story, and environment.

 

Interviewer: What aspects of a game are you primarily concerned with in UX research?

Laura: All aspects really, including game mechanics, interactions, and the overall experience. We ensure the game is engaging and aligns with the studio's vision.

Mark: Adding to that, we assess if game mechanics are clear and enjoyable. This includes navigation, character development, story coherence, and multimodal elements like audio instructions.

 

Interviewer: What does playtesting typically involve?

Laura: It varies from short-term, focusing on a game's "vertical slice," to longer sessions spanning multiple days. A vertical slice is a fully playable section of the game, representing the core features and experience. It helps us understand the look, feel, and flow of the game as a whole.

 

Interviewer: Can you speak about different durations of playtesting?

Mark: Absolutely. We conduct longitudinal testing, where we revisit a game over a lengthy period, observing changes in player behaviour and game dynamics. This contrasts with single-session testing, where we evaluate the game based on the participants often playing only a “vertical slice”.

Laura: In both cases, we frequently test with groups of people. The default approach is to let them play for a while, then retroactively discuss their experience. We usually encourage the discussion between participants as a tool to generate better insights. We also use questionnaires to have players rate different aspects of the game in a more quantified manner.

 

Interviewer: In recent years, VR and AR gaming have become more and more main stream, and users can now run quite elaborate simulations using only their smartphones and connected VR / AR headsets.  Can you elaborate on testing for VR and AR in gaming?

Laura: VR and AR bring unique challenges, like ensuring physical safety and comfort. We test for motion sickness, ease of interaction, and immersion. The feedback loop is crucial as these technologies evolve rapidly. User comfort is paramount, especially in VR, where physical disorientation can be a significant issue.

Mark: In VR and AR, we also pay close attention to the user's environment. We test different settings to ensure games are adaptable and responsive to real-world surroundings. This includes assessing how virtual elements interact with physical space and ensuring the experience remains consistent across varied environments.

Laura: For AR games, we often visit participants in their homes. It's only in a realistic environment that we can truly evaluate the experience, seeing how digital elements blend with the physical world and ensuring a seamless gameplay experience. This approach helps us understand how players interact with AR elements in their everyday surroundings, which is crucial for designing intuitive and engaging AR games.

Mark: VR demands a high level of immersion. We test extensively on how players navigate and interact within a virtual space, ensuring the experience is intuitive and engaging. We focus on the fluidity of movement, interaction with virtual objects, and the overall sensory experience, aiming to create a believable and absorbing virtual world.

 

Interviewer: Do you often engage in iterative testing with game studios?

Laura: Yes, iterative testing is integral in game development. The game development life cycle naturally lends itself to this process. As games are developed in stages, testing at each stage allows for feedback to be implemented before the next development phase begins. This approach helps in refining game elements progressively, ensuring that the final product aligns closely with player expectations and the studio's vision. It's more efficient to make adjustments during development than post-release. Regular testing sessions, sometimes as frequent as every few weeks, allow us to track changes and their impacts on user experience in real-time. This continuous loop of feedback and improvement is essential for creating compelling and successful games.

 

Interviewer: Why should game studios rely on external agencies for playtesting?

Laura: External agencies offer impartiality, which is vital for unbiased feedback. Developers can become too close to their projects, missing key issues that fresh eyes can spot.

Mark: Additionally, agencies like ours ensure data security and handle the logistical aspects of testing. This allows game studios to focus on development while we take care of gathering and analyzing user feedback.

Laura: We also bring a diverse pool of testers, providing a broader range of perspectives that a studio might not have internally.

 

Interviewer: How does game testing differ from other client work?

Mark: Game testing focuses on making games challenging yet enjoyable, unlike the transactional nature of app or website testing, where the goal of UX research usually is to optimize the interface’s efficiency.

 

 

Curious about international UX testing? 🧐 Get in touch with us to discuss!

A cozy Christmas table with a laptop, gifts, a cup of cocoa, and festive decorations, showcasing creativity and humor for the holidays.

The ‘Christmas Prompts’ - Practical & Fun Ideas for the Festive Season

AI & UXR, TRENDS

A futuristic humanoid figure made of glowing digital code fades into a neural network background, symbolizing AI and consciousness.

Hollywood’s as AIs vs ChatGPT: What Film AIs Have In Common With ChatGPT (And What They Don’t)

AI & UXR, CHAT GPT, HUMAN VS AI

Medieval image of a scholar with a scroll, surrounded by floating symbols representing errors and hallucinations.

Calculating With AI: A Story of Mistakes and Coincidences.

AI & UXR, OPEN AI, HUMAN VS AI

A dark, satanic-themed image featuring a menacing devil's head with horns, surrounded by gothic and occult symbols, including pentagrams and flames. The phrase 'The Devil is in the Details' appears in bold gothic font in the center, with red and black colors dominating the background.

Everything You Need to Know About Tokens, Data Volumes and Processing in ChatGPT

AI & UXR

Colourful image with typewriter, speech bubbles and pen representing different writing styles; background with fonts in varying typefaces for style diversity.

Your Own Writing Style and ChatGPT: A Guide to Proper Communication

AI & UXR

A women yells at a robot.

Being Nice Helps - Not Only With People, but Also With AI

AI & UXR

A face split down the middle with the left half being a robot and the right half a woman.

Male, Female, Neutral? On a Journey of Discovery With an AI - Of ‘Neutrality’ and Gender Roles

AI & UXR

A floating robot between many symbols of the English and German language.

German or English? How the Choice of Language Influences the Quality of AI Answers

AI & UXR

Image of a podcast cover on the topic of quality in UX research with two women on the cover.

Podcast: Why the quality of UX research can sometimes be a challenge

UX, UX INSIGHTS, UX QUALITY

Two people sitting at a table in a office in front of a laptop and discussing

Why User Research Is Essential: The Most Common Objections and How to Refute Them

UX INSIGHTS, STAKEHOLDER MANAGEMENT, OBJECTION HANDLING, ADVANTAGES USER RESEARCH

Market square in a typical German town with fountain and half-timbered houses

10 Tips for UX Research in Germany

HOW-TO, UX INSIGHTS, BEST PRACTICES, UX IN GERMANY

plastic toy car with toy passengers

In-Car-Gamification: What Do We Actually Do When the Car Drives Itself?

AUTOMOTIVE UX, AUTONOMOUS DRIVING, GAMIFICATION

Woman using her phone while driving

The Future of My Car: My Smartphone on Wheels

AUTOMOTIVE UX, CONNECTIVITY, DIGITISATION

Different medical devices & medications in packaging

Accessibility in Healthcare: Underestimated Pitfalls With Packaging & Labelling

HEALTHCARE, ACCESSIBILITY, REGULATIONS

man driving a car at sunset

Digital Companion or Minimalist Assistant - How Much Is Too Much for German Drivers?

AUTOMOTIVE UX, VOICE ASSISTANTS, TRENDS

different video game controllers

Inside the Game: Exploring the State of Gaming UX - Where Fun Meets Function!

UX INSIGHTS, EXPERT INTERVIEWS, GAMING UX

A skyline of Sydney

A Deep Dive into UX Testing: Australia's Unique Role and Insights Revealed

UX INSIGHTS, EXPERT INTERVIEWS, UX IN AUSTRALIA

Elder adult using video call to consult doctor

The Importance of Patient-Centricity in the Development of Digital Health Applications

MHEALTH, HUMAN-CENTERED DESIGN

AI generated Graphic of an Android using a laptop

AI in User Research: A Case Study on Analyzing International Surveys using ChatGPT

AI & UXR, HUMAN VS AI, HOW-TO

A modern car from the outside

Revolutionizing Vehicle Interactions: Exploring the Future of HMIs at the 2023 car.HMI Conference

HMI, CAR.HMI CONFERENCE, TRENDS

 RELATED ARTICLES YOU MIGHT ENJOY 

INTERVIEWER

Jan Panhoff

started working as a UX professional in 2004 after completing his M.Sc. in Digital Media. For 10 years he supported eBay as an embedded UX consultant. His focus at uintent is on automotive and innovation research.

Moreover, he is one of uintent's representatives in the UX Alliance, a global network of leading UX research and design companies around the globe.

bottom of page